Thread:Loveable Cats/@comment-45429750-20200824064826/@comment-27171758-20200825084108

Ok. So.... shouldn't the same thing apply to Apple? He really doesn't seem to be a main character because he only appears in a few episodes/videos. He just appears in the first appearance of the Annoying Orange and remakes of the very first Annoying Orange episode where he dies by getting knifed and doesn't come back. But, he later appears in The Microwave Effect where Orange, Pear, Midget Apple and Marshmallow travel back in time where Apple was revived because he discovered that he was going to get knifed and then avoids Knife and the future shows if he was still alive, he would be the king of the apples and would be taking over the kitchen. So, to prevent this from happening, Orange and his friends travel back in time where Apple gets knifed and seemingly dies for real. Despite his death, however, he appears in the opening of The High Fructose Adventures of Annoying Orange which could be an unintentional mistake because he didn't actually appear in any episodes of the series, it was another apple who was the main apple in the TV series) and then later appeared in a flashback in the Creepy Pasta video where he was bored by Pear's Algebra lesson. But, other than that, he doesn't appear in any other videos/episodes and he is still remaining deceased and is mostly just mentioned.

In fact, he appeared in less episodes/videos than Passion Fruit, Grandpa Lemon and Liam the Leprechaun. Because of my reasons I just explained, I think he should also be removed from the Main Characters category. If he appeared in lots of episodes just like other characters such as Pear, Midget Apple, Marshmallow, Grapefruit or Orange himself, he would've been either a main or recurring character.