Blueberry Pancake is the main antagonist of Judge Waffle. As the plaintiff of the case of himself against Squash (judged by Walter Waffle), he claims that Squash had squashed him the other day and he had to get cosmetic surgery to look like that. Walter Waffle was skeptical at this fact since he looked fine to him, until he claimed that before the accident, he was a blueberry muffin, making the injury a more serious deal. Squash's only defense is that the one who squashed Blueberry Pancake was a one-armed man with a gavel, which was almost accepted immediately by Judge Waffle, until Blueberry yelled that he was a muffin. Before he can accept it, he is reminded of the one-armed man again. Judge Waffle eventually decided that he needs evidence of the squashing. As part of evidence, he presented his appearance before the accident (but strangely not his appearance of what he looked like before surgery). It was implied that he was trying to frame Squash to get the chin of "Gourd Clooney", but he immediately denies it, saying he's a victim. The one-armed man appears at the end of the episode, crushing and killing most of the jury, Blueberry Pancake, and Judge Waffle.
A chart showing the appearance of Blueberry Pancake before and after the fateful squashing.